Hand-Shadow Light Test

No light meter needed. Use your hand, a sheet of white paper and 30 seconds to find out what kind of light a spot really gets.

1. Put white paper where the plant will go. Hold your hand 12 in (30 cm) above it, around midday. What does the shadow look like?

2. Is it a sunny day?

How the hand-shadow test works

Plants live on light. The amount of light a spot gets decides which plants can grow there — far more than watering or fertilizer. The problem is that our eyes are terrible at judging it: a room that looks bright to us can have less than a tenth of the light found right next to the window, because light fades quickly with distance.

A shadow is an honest measure. Strong, direct light makes a sharp, dark shadow. Weaker, scattered light makes a soft, fuzzy one. When there is very little light, the shadow almost disappears. Gardeners have used this trick for decades because it needs no tools and works in any home.

What each result means

Bright light (sharp shadow)

The spot gets direct sun or very strong light, usually right at a south- or west-facing window in the US (north- or west-facing in Australia). Cacti, succulents, jade plants, aloe and ponytail palms love it. Many leafy tropicals can sit here too if a sheer curtain softens the afternoon sun.

Medium light (soft shadow)

This is what plant labels call “bright, indirect light”: a bright room where the sun doesn’t hit the leaves directly, or a few feet back from a sunny window. Pothos, monstera, philodendron, spider plants, peperomia and most popular houseplants do best here.

Low light (faint shadow)

Typical of rooms with north-facing windows in the US (south-facing in Australia), corners far from windows and hallways. Only shade-tolerant plants handle it: ZZ plant, snake plant, cast iron plant, parlor palm and plain green pothos. They will grow slowly, so water them less often.

Too dark (no shadow)

If you can’t see any shadow at midday on a sunny day, the spot can’t support a plant long-term. A full-spectrum LED grow bulb in a normal lamp, on a timer for 10–12 hours a day, fixes it cheaply.

Tips for an accurate reading

  • Test at midday on a clear day, lamps off.
  • Test the exact spot where the plant will sit — 3 feet can change the result.
  • Repeat in winter. The sun is lower and days are shorter, so a medium spot in summer can become low light in December in the US (June in Australia).
  • Watch the plant. Long, stretched stems and small new leaves mean it wants more light, whatever the test said.

Light meter apps vs. the hand test

Free light meter apps measure light in lux (or foot-candles) with your phone’s front sensor. They are useful for comparing two spots, but different phones can disagree by a lot, and the sensor points the wrong way unless you hold the phone carefully. As a rough guide, bright light is above about 10,000 lux, medium is 2,500–10,000, low is 500–2,500, and below 500 lux most plants slowly starve. The hand test lands in the same buckets without installing anything.

Which window is best?

In the US, Canada and the UK, south-facing windows get the most sun, west-facing get hot afternoon sun, east-facing get gentle morning sun and north-facing get the least. In Australia and New Zealand, swap north and south: north-facing windows are the bright ones. East-facing windows are a safe bet almost everywhere because morning sun is rarely strong enough to scorch leaves.

Want the full explanation with photos of each shadow? Read our hand shadow light test guide. Next, find out how often to water a plant in that light.

Frequently asked questions

When should I do the hand shadow test?

Around midday on a clear, sunny day, with lamps off. Light changes during the day, so a test at 9am or on a cloudy day will read darker than the spot really is.

How far should my hand be from the paper?

About 12 inches (30 cm) above a sheet of white paper placed exactly where the plant will sit, with your hand between the paper and the window.

Is a light meter app better than the hand test?

Phone light meter apps give a number in lux or foot-candles and are handy, but readings vary a lot between phones. The hand shadow test is free, quick and accurate enough to pick the right plant.

Does a north-facing window count as low light?

In the US, a north-facing window usually gives medium-to-low light with no direct sun. In Australia it is the opposite: north-facing windows are the sunny ones and south-facing windows are the dim ones.